Comparing Geico to competitors may help you decide which insurance policy is best for you. In regard to pricing, Geico’s most expensive competitor - Liberty Mutual - has premiums that average around $2,227, making the Geico homeowners insurance cost on average around $1,035 less. Geico’s least expensive competitor - Progressive - has premiums that average around $1,056 which is about $157 less than Geico. The majority of competitors offer similar coverage in regards to theft, fire, and storms. State Farm and Progressive offer discounts for cautious homeowners who make an effort to ensure the safety of their home, such as by having fire extinguishers or installing burglar alarms. Another competitor, Allstate, has a similar bundling discount, along with a discount for those over 55 years of age. When looking for a provider, request quotes from multiple companies and carefully compare their coverage policies.