The median Allstate homeowners insurance cost is $930, and this fares pretty low with its competitors. If you were going for a basic Travelers homeowners insurance policy, you might expect to pay around $1,200. They are one of the oldest insurance companies out there, founded in the 1800s, so they are another big name that customers trust. They have earned an A+ BBB rating with accreditation. Though, their rates still come in slightly higher than Allstate’s. If you were looking into getting Progressive for your homeowners insurance, you could expect to pay around $2,044. Their BBB rating is also an A+, but they are not accredited. Again, this all depends on your policy features and what type of coverage you decide to go with. Across the board, Allstate consistently comes in as one of the cheapest options with great coverage for your home. They remain consistent year after year.